The Effectiveness of a Multicultural and Bilingual Education

The Effectiveness of a Multicultural and Bilingual Education 1 There is a lot of controversy concerning our public educational programs. Opinions and lifestyles differ; [-- often] Often what is beneficial for one group of people is counterproductive for another group. Educational issues are complex and sensitive; [-- therefore] Therefore, we must analyze both sides of the issue before we make a decision. Two controversial issues in todays public educational program are multicultural and bilingual education. 2 Some experts believe there are many benefits we, as Americans, can experience in a multicultural education. James A Banks states; An education that reflects the experiences of a nation across its racial, gender and†¦show more content†¦Learning and understanding their culture is one way of uniting our nation. [Combine with previous paragraph?] 4 There are other experts that [who] believe multicultural education is counterproductive to American education. Thomas J Famularo, a former English instructor for the City University of New York argues that multiculturalism is harmful because it does not dive deep enough into the individual cultures. This type of curricula doesn?t give us a united American culture; Instead, it divides us into groups according to our race, gender and social class. Famularo states; Such curricula results in a decline of educational quality (103). Experts claim [whose authority?] these divisions will pull our nation even further apart and take the emphasis off our traditional values of family; Church and school then turn to race, gender and sexual preference (Famularo 104). 5 According to Famularo, two fatal flaws undermine multicultural education. The first is that the more the curriculum represents a multicultural test based upon exposure to diversity the more shallow and superficial learning becomes. The second fatal flaw is that it necessarily precludes the single most important requirement for successful education- [--] coherent means to a discernible end (106). Linda Chaves states; If we allow race and ethnic [ ethnicity -- inacurrate quotation] to determine public policy, we invite the kind of cleavagesShow MoreRelated Education Values Essays780 Words   |  4 PagesThree areas in particular that have been eliciting much discussion are bilingual education programs, services within schools for gay and lesbian students, and inclusion of multicultural curricula. Among each of these programs, questions have been raised about their relativity to education and the comprehensive research to prove that these programs are beneficial to students. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp; Bilingual education is a fairly new program, in which foreign-born students learn English forRead MoreBenefits Of Dual Language Bilingual Education784 Words   |  4 Pagesdual language bilingual education strategy is usually employed in public schools. Typically the minority language students and the majority language students are evenly distributed throughout the classrooms. Both languages are used for instruction with evenly distributed 50/50 time. One teacher shall instruct with the home language while other instruction is in English. The two teachers work collaboratively through all the lessons. Since these students are in mainstream education, it is no surpriseRead MoreA Brief Look at Bilingual Education1691 Words   |  7 Pages Bilingual Education- Two-Way Immersion programs According to Martinez-Wenzy, Perez Gandara (2012), two major research by the National Literacy Panel (NLP) and the Center for Research on Education, Diversity and Excellence (CREDE) on effective approaches in the education of ELLs, found that Reading, spelling and writing instruction in the home language facilitates achievement in English. The same authors also found, that ELL students who receive instruction in their Native language outperformRead MoreThe South: Educating a Growing Hispanic Population Essay1168 Words   |  5 Pagespopulation, education concerns of this population have started to arise. In some cases, Hispanics are being over referred to special education programs. This phenomenon is linked to the presence of a language barrier as well as other characteristics of the children in this population (Guiberson, 2009). Although the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) specify that language barriers should be ruled out, it seems that this phenomena contin ues, but could be corrected with proper education techniquesRead MoreCharacteristics Of Culturally Responsive Teaching Essay924 Words   |  4 PagesAn expert teacher shows its effectiveness by creating a classroom community that constantly interacts to grasp better the curriculum. In addition, a teachers’ expertise also consists of being culturally responsive with consideration to the classroom community (Glickman, Gordon, Ross-Gordon, 2014). What are the characteristics and requirements of such a teacher? Glickman et al., (2014) gives out nine characteristics that best describe the expert teacher; the list and definition is below. CharacteristicsRead MoreBenefits Of Bilingual Education1280 Words   |  6 PagesIn many parts of educational development, bilingual education is treated as learning for non-American students. The use of their native language along with the inculcation of English to their vocabulary is the main aim of this program. According to educators, this is more likely an ESL program that would indeed assist foreign nationals living in the American territories to adapt to the society, especially with regards to children who are born in America. This would help the non-Americans to be ‘one’Read MoreHow the Federal Bilingual Education Act of 1968 Ended the War on Poverty1699 Words   |  7 PagesThe purpose of this paper is to examine how the Federal Bilingual Education Act of 1968, ended the War on Poverty. Bilingual education is the use of more than one language to deliver curriculum content. The bilingual education system is designed for students to become proficient in English, and also encourage students to become bi-cultural; and function in two, or more linguistic and cultural groups. The policy expressed U.S commitment to the needs of the growing number of children in the publicRead MoreThe District Handbook1897 Words   |  8 Pagesextra language by explaining that dual language is a form of enriched education and that learning two languages has many cognitive benefits as evidenced by research that has shown how students who participate in Dual Language programs outperform their peers on standardized tests. A full range of services are provided to meet individual needs. One of these services, English as a Second Language, provides support in general education classrooms for students whose first language is not English. The EnglishRead MoreEssay about Bilingual education: The Benefits of Technology1834 Words   |  8 PagesBilingual education: The Benefits of Technology The topic of discussion will introduce how technology can benefit Bilingual education in classrooms across the United States. Alone, Bilingual education is a controversial issue. There are several people and organizations in this country who, for various reasons, are opposed to bilingual education. Minorities in the Classroom It is estimated that by the turn of the century up to 40 percent of the children in the nation’s classrooms willRead MorePrinciples of Mental Health1258 Words   |  5 Pagesclinical mental health counseling practice (CACREP). WHO (2012) identifies intervention principles and strategies, specifically for children and adolescents, as specificity, age, variability and practicability, and evaluation and assessment of effectiveness (WHO). Early intervention occurs in four stages, i.e., detection and assessment, immediate management or treatment, early and late recovery, and continuing care (EPPIC, 2012). During detection and assessment, a specific disorder is perceived